Sammy's All-YOU-CAN-EAT Buffet

Can't decide? Have a little – or a lot – with our all-you-can-eat buffet!
We offer a variety of pizzas, pastas, broasted chicken, soups, garlic bread and a salad bar.

Served daily from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m.
Adults: $8.45, Children: 50¢ per year

Daily Food Specials

Monday - Two medium (12”) one-topping pizzas for $22.95

Tuesday - $2 OFF all appetizers and two-topping pizzas

Wednesday - Buy one pizza get the second 1/2 OFF

Thursday - Medium (12”) one-topping pizza for $9.95.

Friday - Two large (14") one-topping pizzas for $29.95

Saturday - FREE pitcher of soda with purchase of any family-size (16”) pizza

Sunday - Family-size (16") two-topping pizza, cheese bread and pitcher of soda (or 2-liter) for $29.95

*Specials not valid with any other coupons or discounts.


New York Bread Sticks - $6.45
Glazed with garlic butter and Italian seasoning. Served with choice of side sauce.                            

Garlic Bread - $4.95
Six slices of Italian bread covered with our garlic butter recipe. Add cheese - $6.45

Breaded Cauliflower - $8.45

Combo Platter - $10.95
Includes three pieces of cheese bread, mozzarella sticks, cheese kurds and side of marinara sauce.

Traditional - $9.95, Boneless - $10.95
Barbeque, hot, or plain breaded wings with celery and your choice of side sauce.

Mozzarella Sticks - $8.95
Breaded mozzarella cheese sticks served with a side of our homemade marinara sauce.

Whole order - $4.45, 1/2 order - $2.95
Straight-cut fries served golden brown.

Wisconsin Cheese Kurds - $9.45
Genuine Wisconsin "Curds" made by
Kaufhold's Kurds in Ellsworth, WI.

Cheese Stix - $6.95
Creamy garlic sauce mixed with mozzarella and served with choice of side sauce.

Side Sauces - $.95
Marinara, Ranch, Barbeque, Garlic Sauce, Bleu Cheese, Pizza Sauce, Cheese Sauce

Award-Winning Pizza

Our pizzas are made with our secret dough and sauce recipes developed more than 64 years ago, with perfectly-aged mozzarella. We assure you that your choice of toppings are the best and freshest ingredients.

Gluten-friendly crust available on 10" or 12" for $2 more.
Please note: we do our very best to keep our pizzas as gluten-free as possible, however, our kitchen is not 100% gluten-free as flour may at times be present in the air. Please be aware of this if you have very high gluten intolerance.

Pizzas served 10", 12", 14", or 16"

Mozzarella Cheese
$9.00, $12.00, $15.00, $18.00

Vegetarian Special
Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes, black and green olives.
$11.75, $15.25, $19.65, $23.75

Pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, onions and Italian sausage.
$12.45, $16.30, $21.75, $26.50

Sammy's Special
Fresh Italian sausage mixed with onions and green peppers.
$10.35, $14.00, $17.65, $21.85

House Special
A special blend of meats and vegetables including pepperoni, sausage, beef, kosher salami, onions, green peppers and mushrooms.
$12.45, $16.30, $21.75, $26.50

Canadian bacon and pineapple.
$11.00, $15.00, $19.00, $23.00

The Hot One
A spicy mixture of pepperoni and pepperoncini peppers. (Red pepper flakes can be added to sauce upon request.)
$11.00, $15.00, $19.00, $23.00

The Mouse Special
In memory of Greg “Mouse” Bement, long-time Sammy’s customer - Pepperoni and kosher salami, very well done and cut into small pieces.
$11.00, $15.00, $19.00, $23.00

Bacon Cheeseburger
Smoked bits of bacon with beef, onions, cheddar and mozzarella.
$12.45, $16.30, $21.75, $26.50

4 - Meat
Topped with sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon and beef.
$12.45, $16.30, $21.75, $26.50

Taco Pizza
Lettuce, onions, tomatoes, black olives and cheddar cheese with choice of beef or chicken. Includes side of sour cream and salsa.
$12.45, $16.30, $21.75, $26.50

Chicken Cordon Bleu
Canadian bacon, chicken and cheddar cheese. Served with side of bleu cheese.
$12.45, $16.30, $21.75, $26.50

Chicken Alfredo
Creamy Alfredo sauce with diced chicken and topped with mixture of cheeses.
$12.45, $16.30, $21.75, $26.50

BBQ or Buffalo Chicken
Homemade recipe chicken with mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Served with choice of homemade buffalo or BBQ sauce.
$12.45, $16.30, $21.75, $26.50

The Crew Special
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms and extra cheese.
$12.45, $16.30, $21.75, $26.50

Italian Gondola
Canadian bacon, pepperoni, hard salami and mozzarella cheese.
$12.45, $16.30, $21.75, $26.50

Super Supreme (Family-size only)
Literally every ingredient we have!

Additional Toppings
Green peppers, banana peppers, pineapple, onions, jalapenos, anchovies, breakfast bacon, chicken, green or black olives, fresh tomatoes, mushrooms, feta cheese, sauerkraut, or double crust
$1.00, $1.50, $2.00, $2.50